Latest stories

The Innkeeper Who Poisoned Her Guests at Tea

Guests checked into her hotel and didn't check out; she drugged them with oleander before her husband finished the job.

Lavinia Fisher ran a hotel outside Charleston with her husband in the early 1800s. Guests checked in. They did not always check out. She would invite male guests to tea, drug them with oleander, and signal her husband to finish the job while they slept. When authorities came to investigate she attacked a man and threw him from a window. She was arrested, tried and convicted of highway robbery — they couldn’t prove the murders. She was sentenced to hang. On the scaffold she wore her wedding dress. She screamed at the crowd. Her last words were: if any of you have a message for the devil, give it to me. I’ll carry it. Then she jumped before the hangman could act. She hanged herself. On her own terms.

Interesting Fact Lavinia Fisher is considered by many to be America’s first female serial killer though this is debated by historians. Her ghost is one of the most reported hauntings in Charleston today. The Old City Jail where she was held still stands. Tours run nightly.

A note on sources

The claims in this story have not been independently checked for this edition. Where a detail is famous but unproven, we have tried to say so in the text.

Nearby on the Dark Atlas

  • The Gentleman Pirate's Doomed Voyage

    A wealthy Barbados planter walked away from his family and fortune to become a pirate, and it ended on the gallows in Charleston.

  • The Deadly Origin Of The Word Deadline

    Long before it meant a due date, a dead line marked the boundary where Civil War prisoners could be shot on sight.

  • The Pirate Who Wore Smoke And Fire Into Battle

    He lit fuses under his hat brim before boarding ships, becoming a living nightmare that terrified crews into surrender.

  • The Barn Where Lincoln's Killer Fell

    Cornered in a burning tobacco barn, America's most wanted fugitive met a violent end after a twelve-day manhunt.

All stories near Charleston →

← Back to the archive